How long have you seen great games which took musical activities as their main subject? Making music now can be done in front of your game console or computer along with joysticks or plastics music instrument replicas. This is a phenomena of the musical world.
These games incorporates first-rate music, great game play, wonderful graphics and close-to-life simulations. And above all, they are fun to play with and they sells.
Music playing (simulation) games has broaden the access of many music. Many unknown quality bands are now famous because their music was included and could be played in the games. Many rock bands from the former-days are once again become popular because of their hit list was included in the games.
These games have already become the successful beacon of music marketing, reaching youngs and olds. Songs that were once could only be listened to now can be played by the fans accompanied with full bands.
With five-frets guitar and a switch, you can make a similar music played by 19-frets, six-strings guitar, complete with its solos.
From the entertainment perspective, there is nothing wrong with it. People just play it for fun. But from the musical perspective side, we can see that people are more eager to participate in music making, even try to emulate real musicians producing real sounds.
But also from these games, we can see that music making has become an instant process. Hours and hours in a studio practicing is no longer necessary to make music. Just equip yourself with a plastic gear and you are ready to play anything in your playlist.
Guitar Hero has become a cultural phenomenon, played in bars, instead of karaoke, quoted from wiki. But one still does not understand why this guitar playing games was chosen, rather than the real guitar playing. While singing karaoke is still a real singing, guitar simulation is not real guitar playing.
The real music making process may not be as captivating as it used to be. The real painful process of music training will be defeated by the easier and less tiring controller practice. The instant culture has already invaded the land of music.
There are some claims that this kind of games has boost the interest on playing the real thing and endorsing the sense of rhythm.
One is not interested in arguing whether one of those statements true or not. But one should say that how great you play those simulation games, you are still unable to play the real thing. The controller skills and console technology still cannot replace the true skills of guitar playing and real bands with real instruments.
One can only ask, please try to play the real thing. Don’t get cocky because of the skills of playing these games perfectly, but be proud when we can play the real instruments. However. virtual is not real.
Great in car-driving games never makes you a great driver on the streets. Play the games, grasp the reality. So here’s the question,”Want to sound like a pro?” The only answer “Practice real instrument like one.”
Pictures:
Filed under: Art, Music, Opinion , games, guitar hero, rock band



You’ve suggested in one of your posts that music is inclusive, but why I did sense exclusivity in this one? Have you had bad experiences with some level of gamer’s cockiness? ;p
fun juga ngikutin opini2 lo tentang hal2 kayak gini, termasuk yang si robot sapa itu namanya….
people do it for FUN… so, ga perlu repot2 sekolah musik untuk nikmatin FUN nya bermusik. belum lagi ada tantangan high score dsb di game2 itu… i think it’s cool…
well, kayaknya memang udah jamannya ya mike
yaaaaaa… kalo mau dibandingin sama the real one, ya ga adil lah… kayak nanya enak mana ayam goreng sama ayam goreng wax, hwahahahaha,,,,
oversimplifying, mike. don’t forget that in Guitar Heroes (or Frets on Fire, or VOS) the songs are of predefined sets. it has nearly nothing to do with creativity or music making; more like doing DDR with background music, IMO.
the real stuff isn’t going to die. just like how Winning Eleven would never ‘kill’ the real football, or how Counter Strike would never be able to go even beyond AirSoft Gun.
btw, I played Colin McRae and Gran Turismo, and it has nothing to do with my driving skill… don’t even call NFS series for the list.
hohoho…. lots of comments already….
@meltarisa
I just don’t want people under estimate music. Music is inclusive as always, but it’s as difficult as ever… hehehe coz I love it so much…
@ra! and yud1
I think both of you were talking about the same thing…. the virtual one definitely is not the real one, but it can at certain degree keep people from accessing the real one.
People playing WE would spend less time to play real football just because he allocates more time playing the game. It would not kill the real but in turn it will limit the interest to the real thing…
hahaha… mungkin gw terlalu purist untuk hal beginian….hehehe
is it… some kind of jealousy that music are now approached by some not-so-willing-to-learn people?
[/jk,]
no, not really. what I meant to say was, even Guitar Hero compared to playing real guitar is less similar than DDR to a modern dance, but I don’t think that it keeps people from accessing the ‘real’ one; rather it’s in a whole different domain. (case: Guitar Hero and VOS etc)
but beyond that, what really mattered in my mind is that Guitar Hero (or Frets on Fire, or VOS, or whatever on the line) comes nearly nothing close to music playing (and creating) activity: predefined song, relies only on players’ reflects and rhythm, and so on.
oh well. even when I can cook my instant noodle, it won’t stop me from buying some ‘real, well-cooked’ noodle on the shoppe. quite analogous to the Guitar Hero case, IMO.
@yud1 then mikebm:
Ah, oversimplifying was the word I’ve looked for! *thanks, Yud!*
Part of my logical argument suited Yud1’s last comment so yes please, mikebm, have your say about that. :’)
And yes,
I think you’re jealous! *thanks again, Yud*
You did sound overprotective in this writing. Is that how you love? ;p
“Is that how you love? ;p”
*lol*
Haduh gw kena serang… hahaha….
mungkin iya, mungkin ga….. gw sih berharap ga ada remeh-peremehan aja…
iya deh gw nyerah…. hehehe
^
no hard feeling, mate. I didn’t see it coming either.
iya, ini mister blue di sini…hehehe… dimaafkan… hahaha
hihihi…lucu juga bacain komen2 yang di sini
hi
[...] the last couple of weeks, people storming to this blog to search for Guitar Hero article and pictures as it reached more than a thousand page view this [...]
Gee, another elitist article that thinks Guitar Hero players are all losers too lazy to make their own music and they’re killing real music. What a surprise. See, I play Guitar Hero on Expert. I’ve 5 starred a good chunk of the Expert setlist on GH2/GH3; maybe 126/134 songs? Do I feel pretty good about myself? Fuck yes. Do I think I can play a real guitar? Hell no. See, you think no one should have the right to feel good about themselves just because they play a “fake” guitar. They should play a real instrument. I bet you couldn’t pick up a GHtar and play one song on Easy, and if you did fail, I would laugh at you until the cows came home. Apparantly millions of people feel good about themselves when they play this game and extract some form of entertainment from it, so why shit on their parade just because you think yours is better?
@moot
I think you deserve yourself a credit for playing it as everybody does… but I use my perspective as a music lover, not a game lover… How ever the games cannot replace any real band playing in the studio along with yourself…
[...] Others view the games as a dilution of musical purity. http://mikebm.wordpress.com/2008/07/03/the-truth-behind-music-playing-games/ The author of this blog argues that the playing of the music as a game diminishes or entirely [...]
gago kayo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Guitar hero is not music making, it is a fun simulation game. at the very best it is midi programming in an extremely limited sense and will help you get around the picking and fretboard navigation part of guitar in an extremely limited sense. get some real midi software and experience the freedom of unrestricted music making potential. they have made midi really simple these days.
there is more to guitar than guitar hero